Skip to main content

Tournament Scoring - Part 1: Tournament Games are Variants

Tournaments have come to be a big part of Diplomacy, whether face-to-face or online.  If you're running a tournament you need to be able to find a winner, and so a scoring system has to be introduced.  In this series of posts I'm going to look at different types of scoring systems and discuss the pros and cons of each one.  And I'll end the series by discussing my own, as yet, prototype system.


The first thing to be aware of is that a scoring system will change the way people play the game.  It has to do.  If you're playing and you need to do well then you need to play to the system.  This means that the way the system affects the way Diplomacy is played.

Tournament games are already a variant of Dip.  Ideally, they wouldn't be.  Players would be able to play x number of games and play them as they would any other game.  In FTF play, you'd expect the game to run until they're finished or time runs out.  Online, there should be plenty of time to finish the game.

Realistically, however, this isn't the case.  FTF tournament games tend to have an game end date (GED).  I'm told - I don't know because I don't live there - that tournament games in North America tend to only have a GED for the final round of games.  That's good - although the final round is the round when the winner is actually chosen so, arguably, the one game that ought to be played to a natural end.

In Europe, this isn't the case.  Games are played until they reach the GED.  And applying a GED automatically means games are variants.

It would seem that if the tournament is being played online, there shouldn't be a problem with playing each game to a natural end.  People don't have to go back to normal life at the end of the weekend, for instance.

However, online tournament games tend to have a GED too because the tournament needs to end at some point.  I know of some tournaments that haven't implemented an GED, such as the Diplomacy World Cup.  That specific tournament has been running for years.  Frankly, who is interested in that kind of event?

Also realistically you're not just playing a single game.  It isn't possible to keep each game 'standing alone' because you have to keep in mind that this game is part of a series of games.  Throwing caution to the wind in one game might ruin your chances in the tournament altogether.

Given, then, that tournament games are already a form of variant (and that online games are themselves a variant) does it matter what the scoring system is?  We're already playing a variant; adding any scoring system makes it more of a variant; does it matter what that scoring system looks like?

I believe strongly that it does.  If the scoring system changes the objectives of the game, then that is an issue that should be considered.  If the scoring system changes the way the game is played, then that is an problem, especially if that change is exaggerated by the system.

When it comes right down to it, of course, if you enter a tournament you should play to the scoring system in that tournament.  I've not entered online tournaments because I don't think the scoring system will produce good games.  But I've also entered tournaments where, although I've not agreed with the scoring system, I simply wanted to play!

TOURNAMENT SCORING series:

  1. Tournament Games are Variants
  2. What should a good scoring system do?
  3. Draw Size Scoring (DSS)
  4. Supply Centre Scoring (SCS)
  5. Other Scoring Systems
  6. Summarising the Problem with Scoring Systems
  7. The Mystery Scoring System Explained
  8. Does Mystery Scoring meet the objectives?

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

The Embassy Journal

You know, I have realised that I probably bang on too much.  What can I say?  I like the sound of my own writing (my voice, until laryngitis kicks in when I begin to sound like Barry White, is slightly too high pitched and squeaky). This led me to realise that I should probably be looking at different ways to put out what I want to put that's longer-winded than the long-winded stuff I publish here. And so The Embassy Journal was born. This is my zine, written to accompany the blog, but with articles and a smattering of other stuff.  You can get it from the link above, which will lead you to the first issue (March 2020).  Let me know what you think. All issues will be published on The Embassy Journal page on this blog, where you can also find subscription and contribution info.

The Ethics of Diplomacy - Part 7: Tournaments and Teamplay

Teamplay during an online game is likely to be banned under metagaming rules.  It's clearly unfair if a couple of players enter a game to play together, supporting each other and attacking others, when everyone else in the game is playing as an individual.  Well, I say clearly but that isn't always the case; some people just don't think there's anything wrong with it. However, it is also something that can arise in FTF tournaments and it has often been banned, for obvious reason... again, I'd say obvious reasons. It is (or was) common for a tournament or convention to combine individual competitions with team competitions.  A local club or organisation might have a number of players attend, therefore, and this is often true when there wasn't a team competition, simply because it's nice to go with your mates. It didn't take long for teamplay to be outlawed.  What was happening was that players from the same club would help each other out in ga...

The Ethics of Diplomacy - Part 9: Mind Games

I've separated this from gamesmanship because it is something different.  However, mind games have the same impact on the Dip community as gamesmanship, for very similar reasons. Mind games are anything that you can do to get under the skin of another player.  They can be irritants, impoliteness or meant to simply build paranoia. Silence Sending messages and getting no response is frustrating.  I know - I send a lot of messages and find it annoying if I'm getting nothing back from someone with whom I'm supposed to be working. Now, what happens when that silence is  deliberate ?  When someone decides that they're not going to answer messages, or keep their answers to a minimum?  Why would they do  that ? Well, it is usually to cause some disruption in your thinking.  If you're concerned that she isn't messaging back, you're going to be concerned about what your plans were going to be. I know at least one player who hates this,...